Survivor: Most One-of-a-Kind First-Time Player of Every Season (1-42) [Copyright Claimed]

Here are my picks... For simplicity's sake, I'll leave out the seasons where my pick is the same as yours. Borneo - Rudy Australia - Jerri Amazon - Heidi Vanuatu - Eliza Palau - Angie Fiji - Yau-Man Micronesia - Kathy Gabon - Randy Samoa - I hate to admit it but Russell H South Pacific - Stacey One World - Tarzan Philippines - Abi-Maria Blood vs. Water - Vytas Worlds Apart - Rodney Heroes vs. Healers vs. Hustlers - Alan Ghost Island - Chris David vs. Goliath - I'm inclined to say Angelina but Christian is a very valid answer that I can't fault you for! Edge of Extinction - Reem 41 - Shan And to update with the seasons that hadn't aired yet when you posted this... 43 - Cody 44 - Carolyn 45 - Technically Bruce is a returnee so... Emily 46 - Q

For the record, "unique" and "likeable" are not always interchangeable, as 0:39 should show. Also, I excluded returnees because (1) it's hard not to judge them based on the aggregate of all their seasons, and (2) they are inevitably favored by the edit over newbies.

I thought for sure I was gonna be seeing Jason Siska’s face lol

The fact that Greg and Sean haven't returned is a travesty.

I like this idea, do you mind if I use it for Big Brother Canada?

Colby one of a kind????

29 men & only 9 women made your list

i’d have Kimmi for Ao, Zoe for Marquesas, Rory for Vanuatu, and Caryn for Palau

Joanna over Rob C??

Mostly a sausage fest 🤢🤮