Building A Perfect Survivor Season - Survivor: Atlantis

Published 2020-09-03
What would we do if given the money and power to create the perfect season of Survivor for a cast of newbies? Well... I would create Survivor: Atlantis!

Analytical Strategy -    / @analyticalstrategy  

Logo Winner - VJ4rawr2 youtube.com/vj4rawr2

Runner Ups...
Ben The Object
RicardoNarwhal
Patrick Bedard
JPB Productions
Qartoon Productions
MrMonkey131

Patreon - www.patreon.com/onceuponanislandchannel

Facebook - www.facebook.com/onceuponanislandchannel
Twitter - twitter.com/upon_island
Instagram - www.instagram.com/once_upon_an_island_channel/
Email - [email protected]

All Comments (21)
  • @lindsayg7672
    they should hide idols underwater , like to go along with the “Atlantis” theme
  • Jeff Probst needs to see this Edit: Everyone who is seeing this, tweet this to Jeff Probst
  • @tjflash60
    This would be a great season. Survivor Atlantis "Sink or Swim"
  • @jsn.9769
    you got me hyped for a season that'll never happen omg
  • Thanks for having me! Hope you all enjoyed the video and head over to Analytical Strategy for more Survivor content!
  • @stacuu2222
    Totem should be a trident with a dispatchable "horns", also one of the first three tribes should be "Hades" instead of "Athena" (it would make all tribes named after trinity of God-brothers) or if there would be just two tribes, it could be called "Athena" (patron of Athens) and "Ares" (patron of Sparta) so to recreate great conflict between two ancient powerhouses.
  • @user-db9vy2gh3v
    Imagine a survivor where 20 contestants start on 1 tribe then at every immunity challenge they split up into into teams to participate in the challenge, then the team that loses goes to tribal and they repeat this process of different teams until the merge (10 contestants) and have individual immunity challenges but the point is for everyone to be on one beach from the get go and switch up of tribes every episode.
  • @VJ4rawr2
    Loved the twist around the loved one challenge. Removing food is a great idea. I can see this being used in other scenarios too. Perhaps a tribe wins immunity, and they're offered a huge feast AFTER winning if they give immunity away? I would have added the challenge where survivors have to vote for each other in different categories. Who is the most annoying.. Who is going home next... Who would pose nude for playboy (lol). That was a classic and it's a great pause that allows non physical players to win. Final thing... bring back the camp raids. Sandra ripping down the other tribes shelter to steal their tarp was iconic. Great video. Really loved it. Well done!
  • @rageofstate2695
    Three tribes: Zeus, Poseidon and Hades. The camps resemble their respective God. The Zeus tribe is in a mountainous or wooded area, the Poseidon tribe by the water and the Hades tribe on an open plain or a place with lots of stone. The challenges could be based around the Twelve Labors of Hercules.
  • @OhSkyeLanta
    Me: sees in title Atlantis "Nice, nice" Video: "it will be set in Greece." Me: smashing the like "NIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIICE!"
  • @eastonagnew57
    I love how much thought you guys put into this, I love the collaboration, and I really like all your ideas, like bringing back a lot of old school stuff and limiting advantages to a few idols. This season needs to happen!!
  • This is unique, I like this style of video. And definitely checking that other guys channel.
  • @rohanbegg7619
    I just thought of a way to cast, make it like a last chance season to people who have played 2-4 times before and haven't won, and make it like the last chance for them as survivors, and it could be called Atlantis: Sink or Swim
  • @patrickb2458
    Excellent video man, you rock! The design of the logo you chose is visually rich and I think represents the direction in which the show is going the best out of all of the other logos! Great editing too btw, that's a lot of work! Keep it going!
  • @bc5163
    No returnees and therefore no pre-game alliances ✅ Reward challenges ✅ Not too many tribe swaps ✅ No Edge of Extinction ✅ No fire tokens ✅ No Redemption Island ✅ No Blood vs Water ✅ No One World ✅ No Ghost Island ✅ No Island of the Idols ✅ Limit on number of idols ✅ Idols not re-hidden ✅ No other advantages ✅ No final 4 fire making challenge ✅ Return to classic jury format ✅ Full reunion episode ✅ Other things: - Forbid whispering at tribal council - Have a Survivor intro showing the cast with the classic theme (at least for the first episode)
  • @zacharylee2173
    I love the old school challenges. It does feel like most challenges now is just an obstacle course that ends with a puzzle
  • @jaehurd3524
    Should definitely make more of these and go into more detail on stuff like tribal and idol designs, and maybe some light twists that fit the thene
  • Happy that Analytical Strategy is on this video, because I have been watching him since his first upload.