New Haven Pizza Review! (Frank Pepe's, Sally's, Modern, BAR)

So they were cold? I think you should have ordered and ate them each individually. You can’t rate cold pizza.

Lived in CT for 40 years and I've always thought Modern was #1 in taste, Sally's #2 and Pepe's #3 but they're all good and any one of them is a treat. Modern's taste is incredible. Their flavor is just perfect. Over all the years I'd say Pepe's tends to be the most burnt, Modern the most floppy and occasionally oily but it's still King.

All the pizza’s looked cooled down. You should have graded them as you picked them up. Rookie review.

Modern has always been my favorite! Plus you don’t have to wait in a long line. Love it!

Modern surprised me so much! Didn’t think anything could beat Pepe’s!

I loved your reaction when you bit into Modern’s slice 😂❤ I’ve gotta try it!

From memory, Pepe's looked less regular, more like a "New Haven abeetz" before they branched out. I think that they became more standardized. My favorite was always Sally's but Modern and Pepe's not far behind. I never had ahbeetz at Bar while I was sober. Zuppardi's in West Haven is right up there

Good review, but if you eat them fresh at the table, no box......I have to flip Sally's and Modern. When Sally's nails a pie and you eat it right out of the oven, it's ridiculous. Plus, their OG tomato pie is really the top of the heap. The sauce is just next level in my opinion. If you're a sauce lover, it's Sally's. If you're a cheese lover, it's Modern. I lived in Florence Italy for almost a year and ate pizza all over Italy, including Naples and Rome. The freshness of ingredients and overall taste of some of those pies were spectacular, but if I had to eat one pie for the rest of my life it would be the OG tomato at Sally's.

Nice video for your 4th video on your channel!!! You’re doing a good job! Good luck!

What a perfect review of exactly what everyone is looking for. A comparison of the top 4 places in New Haven. Thanks so much for doing this, and doing it right. Hopefully this vid blows up for ya

Modern’s my favorite too. Have it every week.

Oh mannn! Great reaction man, thought you were going to pick Sally’s 😮

awesome video, last one I haven't tried yet is BAR but the others are so good it makes it hard to go elsewhere

This young man doesn’t know how good Pepe’s used to be back in the day. They have definitely changed the recipe since the takeover and expansion. My parents started taking us there in the early 60’s and if you think it is good now, then you surely missed a great thing.

Going to New haven in 2 weeks to see Chris Webby. Definitely will be trying some Sally's, and modern pizza. Thx fir the video

It’s the chuckle after Sally’s for me. Good stuff

you did a great job no doubt.....and you loved what you did......keep going dude....well wishes!

That pizza looks so good! And so does the man eating the pizza!!! 😍🥵

ahh great video man!!!!!!!

Great pizza comparison, pal 👍