Yes... Developers actually warned low-honor players in this scene

Reverend: "Just Make sure you go say Howdy Partner to 1000 people."

"You don't get to live a bad life and have good things happen to you."

-Arthur Morgan

I found it interesting how in high honour the conductor yells all aboard before Reverend leaves, maybe showing that Reverend would have talked longer if he had a few more minutes. But in low honour Reverend leaves before the conductor yells this, showing that Reverend had no more to say.

If it’s a bad story, I’ll do an evil play through for laughs. If it’s a decent story, I’ll do a good play through and then an evil one. But if it’s a great story, I can’t bring myself to play it evil.

*Proceeds to ride straight to Saint Denis and greet every NPC in the city for max honor*

The conversation with the sister is probably better in my opinion. She is an outside influence, someone who isn't an outlaw or criminal, and she still praises Arthur in spite of him openly confessing his criminal past to her. Instead of running to the nearest authorities and turning Arthur in, she saw him as a struggling child of God who needed help and guidance. It goes to show that anyone can change course in their lives and progress and move forward and become better no matter what they've done in their past.

This game has better acting, cinematography and dialogue than some movies, I swear...

You lived your way... You die your way 😢

Notice reverend's behavior, as well as the way he's not holding the book, which held his morphine injections. In High Honor it's not in his hands, which makes him look a bit more hurried, which can hint to him quitting, as for Low Honor he's still holding it and also acts more ""naturally""

I kinda like the low honour dialogue better - more fits the position Arthur's in - but high honor story's better

The whole scene is read different. Even the words that are written the same are spoken with a different tone. So well done.

"Save those you can, let the rest rot and look after yourself"
Actual life advise

For me the canon conversation is with sister calderon

Man the subtle changes! In high honour, Arthur taps his arm in a polite way to get him to sit with him. In the low honour Arthur just sits, thinking only about himself.

Fun Fact : this cutscene only unlocks if you don't meet the sister at any point of time.

In my first playthrough I didn't met her I got this, in second I met her I didn't got this.

You can tell how goddamn terrified Swanson is in this scene. You can really tell how fear inducing Arthur was even up to and after he started really getting sick.

The Rev scoots away from Arthur remembering he’s got TB 😂

Game is still beautiful after six years.

I wish I could go back in time and play this game over for the first time. It's truly a one of a kind experience.

Idk that “I’m afraid” moment when he’s talking to the sister is in my opinion the most sad and humanizing moment for Arthur as he finally lets his guard down and admits that he knows he’s done bad things and is afraid god will not welcome him to heaven as he’s not afraid of dying but he is afraid of what might be waiting for him after but the sister comforts him saying he is a good man and will be just fine