Vocal Coach Reacts to Shila Amzah - Listen｜國外聲樂老師的茜拉初體驗 #shilaamzah #茜拉 #我是歌手

Her name is Shila Amzah, she's not from China but a Malay ethnic from Malaysia. She went into China market around 10 + years ago entering some singing competitions trying to create a market and branding for herself and she did achieve millions of followers, much more than what she could achieve back in Malaysia in such a short time. What's more amazing was Shila learned Chinese language (Mandarin) while in the midst of those competitions as usually 99.99% Malay people usually do not know Chinese language in Malaysia but fluent with English though. She's not at the levels of singers like Zhou Shen and many other top tier Chinese singers you reacted to but she's smart and dares to try breaking into Chinese market. She's now back to Malaysia but occasionally being sought after in China for some events. I know these detailed information because I'm a Malaysian who followed her some years when she was in China.

茜拉我很喜歡 在歌手節目中很令人深刻印象 實力派 她節目中唱的rolling in the deep 和最長的電影超級好聽 而且她給人的感覺也很可愛😊

You put singers at a different level. Your comments are amazing. I like it when you point out where and how things are done in different places in the song. 🫡🫡🫡 And, you have an amazing voice!

Super proud of Shila!!! 🇲🇾🇲🇾❤️❤️

Dalam nyanyian, kita kena identiti sendiri. Sebagai vocal coach, setiap lagu yg dibuat untuk setiap penyanyi, mempunyai kekuatan vokal dan teknik nyanyian tersendiri. Shila menyanyikan lagu ni mengikut bersesuaian vokal dan teknik dia supaya lagu ini seperti lagunya sendiri...

I think listen has been covered by so many artists around the world, and Shila was trying to sing in her style and her way, and I liked it 🤟

well, its a damn competition, it would be boring if she's sang like the original. she has her own identity. its her own style. would love to see Ms. Roz sing it.

She made her own rendition based on her capability....make it work ❤❤❤

Thanks for honest comments from coach rozette, love you!! Start to follow your live song , appreciate

Why u guys all so offensive , she didn’t even say anything hurtful , everytime she said something she didn’t like and immediately follow by saying something might not be necessary bad , I think she is being honest and kind , come on everybody. Open your mind . Don’t be so “glasses heart”

從這段就可以看出,她評華語歌手有多"客氣"了😂😂😂 論實力與技巧,Shila是贏過很多華語女歌手的

這才是真正的點評 很可愛的小女生 我是歌手中喜歡的歌手之一 她在自己的家鄉可是國寶級哦

在我是歌手節目當中鄧紫棋說過,相信要學習两百年唱歌也不及茜拉,而茜拉好似成為马來西亞國寶級歌手,相信茜拉唱功及個人特色都非常優秀,已沒有可挑釁評論,只有喜愛不喜愛😂

老师真实的评语其实能让一位歌手学到更多～ ❤❤❤

老師這麼嚴格完全不意外，她自己本身就有COVER這首歌了(在這個頻道)，想當然熟悉度基本上是最頂的；再加上老師本來就是忠於原曲派，茜拉的表現已經很好了哈哈哈~

Shila 表演过的歌曲, 想你的夜(原唱：关喆)，印象非常深刻，她唱得很好听很感动，请让老师看她唱这首歌。最长的电影和洋葱也不错，谢谢！

I think it is not fair to judge and compare her to Beyoncé. She is a great singer on her own merit..If everyone sounds the same then how boring it would be…

She is so much more strict this time round. Got a shock!!!

finally omg i have been commenting in many videos now finally review her thanks a lot

茜拉是真的非常厲害很棒的歌手