Why shipping container homes are overrated

4,493,809
0
Published 2022-06-15
They’re fun. They’re also way more difficult to build than they seem.

Subscribe and turn on notifications 🔔 so you don't miss any videos: goo.gl/0bsAjO

Shipping container homes have been a trend for a while, from reality TV shows to housing policy discussions. But the truth is that these homes are a lot more difficult to build than you might think.

It’s easy to think that housing solutions are purely technological, but many obstacles to housing aren’t in construction but in the policies surrounding homebuilding. Moreover, many of the supposed advantages of shipping containers turn out to be more complicated in reality.

Vox’s Phil Edwards spent a night in a shipping container home to see how the experience of staying in a shipping container compares with the reality of building one.

Further Reading:

Mark Hogan’s 2015 opinion piece about shipping containers is a great introduction to the topic: www.archdaily.com/773491/opinion-whats-wrong-with-…
Belinda Carr’s debunking of shipping containers gets into more building science detail:    • 7 reasons why shipping container home...  
She’s also an even-handed critic and made a video about five shipping container successes:    • Top 5 Shipping Container Conversions ...  
You can check out Michael’s Airbnbs here: www.airbnb.com/users/show/329149776

Make sure you never miss behind-the-scenes content in the Vox Video newsletter, sign up here: vox.com/video-newsletter

Vox.com is a news website that helps you cut through the noise and understand what's really driving the events in the headlines. Check out www.vox.com/

Support Vox's reporting with a one-time or recurring contribution: vox.com/contribute-now

Shop the Vox merch store: vox.com/store

Watch our full video catalog: goo.gl/IZONyE

Follow Vox on Facebook: facebook.com/vox
Follow Vox on Twitter: twitter.com/voxdotcom
Follow Vox on TikTok: tiktok.com/@voxdotcom

All Comments (21)
  • @Vox
    Thanks for watching! Have you stayed in container home? Let us know in the comments below 👇
  • The ukranian refugee containers are not repurposed shipping containers. They are specifically made for this purpose. They were used in europe also as vaccination and covid test centers. You just lay them somewhere on the parking lot and voila you have a covid center. That said, they are accually affordable because from day one they are made for their purpose intead of renovated and adjusted which makes the shipping container houses less affordable.
  • @misz3
    I dont think anyone expected to buy a used container for 4k and not have to do a bunch more work.. even if you end up paying 15k for everything, that's a LOT cheaper than a house. Even with how small it is, it's a functional home they own, and for a lot of people that's amazing.
  • As a mechanical engineering undergraduate. It’s not really that impractical. They really aren’t that problematic just because you need to reinforce it if it’s modified. Literally every structure needs specific reinforcements when it’s changed due to the change in force application. Spending 4K per shipping container and a 2k welder you could get a lot done compared to standard housing costs. Architects aren’t engineers, so don’t rely on them so much for engineering specific questions. Usually architects are more into the form than function of a structure, while they still keep function in mind it’s not as pedantic as engineering analysis.
  • @yoholmes273
    Every house needs "reinforcements, a foundation, plumbing, & electric". If these are considered drawbacks then every modern house ever built is considered a "drawback".
  • @xlynx9
    It would have been interesting / useful to see some price comparisons to other methods of building small homes.
  • @BrettHoTep
    I thought it was generally accepted that shipping containers are really only effective as the frame of a house or room. You aren’t just dumping one in a backyard and moving into it without major modifications.
  • Putting 400 grand into a house and then paying mortgage for years after isnt as easy as it seems either right?
  • There is something skeezy about a landlord who is running an air bnb behind an abandoned house in an overgrown lot and they drive up in a BMW.
  • As architecture professional, I would say that anything that gets converted from non-habitation into habitation will take a lot of extra work — hence will then be classified as “overrated” when ubiquitously hyped by the senselessness of mass media.
  • @reyn9355
    i really like how the owner of the airbnb admits that shipping containers take a lot of money to turn into a “home”
  • This video just proved everything I already knew and was ready for I’m absolutely all in for shipping container home
  • @AgrestisAnima
    I lived in a container for 3 months because of renovations. I liked it, it has enough space and honestly, if this was permanent I could decodate it nicely. If there is no alternative for me in the future, I would absolutely choose this as a place to stay.
  • @ntatenarin
    I'll admit, after living in a studio apartment, these shipping container houses don't look so bad!
  • @CULatte
    Turning an intermodal container into housing is impractical, but building emergency housing in the footprint of a container is a good idea. Makes transport and deployment much easier and cheaper.
  • In the right hands, with a good architect, a shipping container home can be quite nice.
  • @Vivian-ks7jr
    These are still cheaper than regular houses? I don’t think most people think you can just move into a shipping container without doing any modification, and if they do, they simply haven’t done any research. This argument did not prove its point.
  • @DaemonEX0
    I lived in one for a good few years back in the Netherlands and honestly it was great. The insulation was top tier, it had a heat pump, and it was extremely affordable. If I'd had to live by myself again, I'd happily move back into one
  • @EvanBoyar
    I would've liked to see the per unit area price comparison between building a shipping container house and a traditional one. I'm not convinced by this video that it's more expensive, just that it's less inexpensive than people who haven't done enough research thought.
  • You have to frame a home so I don’t see why you can’t do that to a shipping container.