The definitive Destiny 2 Season 1-23 and expansion tier list.

Screw season and expansion tier lists, I wanna see a Lore book tier list.

Season of Plunder (aka pirate season) being placed in the High C tier is a glorious pun that I don't think enough people realize or appreciate

I remember when this game first launched 7 years ago and Datto made his initial review, he recalled the EXACT same concern of him telling TimTheTatMan that the best way to level up was with public events... And him saying that same story today when reviewing season 1 just hit me with nostalgia. Never change, Datto.

Curse of Osiris location we couldn’t even use our sparrows. I knew right then it was gonna suck

I started in Arrivals and honestly it was the best for me. It had the most content, plus it was the last season before everything got sunset
EDIT:
Since people aren't understanding, I started playing D2 in Season of Arrivals as it was on the xbox gamepass at the time. I had the experience to play every single piece of now sunset content. All the old DLC, all the old content. I do miss the exotic missions, and campaign missions on Titan. And honestly Curse of Osiris wasn't bad; especially fighting Panoptes. The one strike that had the giant cyclops was good too. Hell, getting to enjoy Black Armoury was great too, still have some of my BA weapons in the vault.

The menagerie was the best activity to play, Gambit had Reckoning and Gambit Prime (I miss prime) and most importantly I had the option to get Bad Juju and Sagira's Shell legitimately through their associated quests.

All in all, as a player who started on the Gamepass; I had a LOT of content to enjoy

Splicer was one of the greatest seasons. I will die on this hill.

Seraph below Dawn is just a crime but I agree with most of the rest.

Season of the Splicer in B tier is a travesty

Season of the Worthy just made me so sad, I played so much during Season of Dawn, guns were cool and had some nice perks and then Worthy had Warmind Cells but locked behind trash guns imo... Not to mention the sheer server instability still gives makes me shiver in terror..
It did have a really cool aesthetic though, I guess it has that

Season 10 was a tough season, but one of my favorite story beats of all time was finding out Lord Felwinter's true origin, so that was definitely points for me

Arrivals should be at least A-tier

I think Black Armory should be A and I get that the activity wasn't anything crazy and it was very bare bones but we had Scourge, Niobe labs, some of the most iconic legendary weapons ever and also some of the most iconic exotics ever. Izanagi's, Le monarque, Anarchy, Jotunn, Last word. I personally also liked the difficulty in the day one volundr forge, though I understand that I am in the minority. It was marketed as an extension to the endgame so I was expecting that difficulty to be honest.

HELL YEAH!! Getting more Mithrax was amazing. I enjoyed being painted a picture of the monster that shakes off the rot of death and calls itself “Saint”

"It's probably not going to be up here"
It was definitely up here

Splicer was the season that got me back into the grind. And I honestly enjoyed it for once in D2.

seraph had one of the best story lines for a season easy S

I'll say this about Dares of Eternity, it remains the only other casual PVE activity that you can do with more than 3 people besides Gambit lol

Season of the Chosen will always be my favourite.

The way I see Forsaken as a season is the Dreaming City and its content, which was very good. My reasoning, it had a 36 week narrative, 3 repeatable story missions, a new location and a public event.... sounds like a season to me

The story for splicer was one of the best destiny has ever told, the content was probably on par or slightly below season of the chosen, but the story elevated it so much.